German election updates
Sign up to myFT Daily Digest to be the first to know about German election news.
The writer is group chief economist at UniCredit
For investors, there is a lot riding on the outcome of the German elections on Sunday to select a new Bundestag that will negotiate a new government coalition and a new chancellor.
While those negotiations will probably last a few months, international investors and partners will be looking for signs from the election outcome on how Germany will meet the need to raise public investment and fund the transition to a greener future.
The German constitution stipulates that the federal government’s structural fiscal deficit must be limited to 0.35 per cent of gross domestic product.
With no realistic hope of a sufficient majority to change the constitution, a number of complicated fiscal constructions are likely. The outcome will not become first-best but below the headlines, big changes are likely to come.
Germany’s next government will almost certainly consist of three parties, led by either the Social Democrats, with Olaf Scholz as chancellor, or the Christian Democrats, with Armin Laschet as chancellor.
During the coalition negotiations, the SPD and CDU will compete to offer the more attractive compromises to potential coalition partners, the Greens and the liberal Free Democrats.
However, if current opinion polls are broadly right, the SPD and Greens will have an alternative majority with the hard-left Linke party. This is not an option either of them would favour, but it is realistic enough to put pressure on FDP to join the so-called Traffic Light coalition of SPD, the Greens and FDP in order to block a centre-left coalition.
Bruegel, the Brussels-based think-tank, estimates that Europe needs to boost investment by 2 per cent of GDP each year for the next 10 years to get on the path to net zero emissions. Almost half of it will need to be public investment.
This would require a sizeable boost to German public investment, which has fallen to just 2 per cent of GDP during the past 10-15 years. Unique among major OECD countries, this has left German net public investment at roughly zero for the past decade, doing nothing more than maintaining the public sector capital stock, at best.
During the years of globalisation and digitalisation, this has been a costly policy mistake in terms of potential growth. The constitutional brake on debt, along with politically expedient spending priorities, including pensions, have been the driving forces behind the under-investment.
In addition, private investment, which runs at a little less than 20 per cent of GDP, broadly at par with other major OECD countries, would need financial incentives to be boosted and redirected towards green and digital objectives.
The major political parties all acknowledge the need to boost investment to secure the green and digital transformation, but that’s where their roads part. The Greens are calling for 1.5 per cent of GDP in extra public investment for each of the next 10 years.
The other major parties have pledged to keep a lid on public outlays, although influential voices within the SPD and CDU have been vocal about the need to boost public investment for the green transformation. The CDU and FDP, in particular, are also calling for incentives for the private sector to do most of the job.
How to create room inside such a shrinking fiscal envelope to boost public investment sufficiently and to create incentives for the private sector to become greener will be a contentious issue during the coalition negotiations.
The transparent, and orderly, way would be to change the constitution to abandon the debt brake, or at least carve out space for climate change investment, as advocated by the Green party; the only major party to do so. But this requires a two-thirds majority in both chambers of parliament; an unlikely outcome of the election.
As a result, the idea of creating extra budgetary funds in which the government injects debt-financed capital for dedicated investments, possibly geared with private capital, has gained traction. Statistically, this would not increase the government’s net debt and, depending on their legal construction, may not count under the debt brake.
While this would be an opaque and suboptimal structure, and one that would complicate the EU’s much-needed attempt to revise its fiscal rules, the good news is that the next German government will almost certainly show sufficient political will and flexibility to finally boost public investment. The exact amount and degree of transparency will depend on the outcome of the election.

