When we are deciding on a partner with whom to share our lives, we care about character. It’s not enough for the person to be good-looking, have a good job or be wealthy. We all know this. But lately, some have been suggesting that in politics, all that matters is that a person is willing to support policies that we favor. We should know better, but for some reason, many of us have somehow forgotten this very basic truth.
What is character? The ancients called it virtue, a word that (for reasons I don’t understand) doesn’t resonate well today. Character is the word we use to describe the way in which people respond to the world around them. Good character is not selfish. It is not destructive. Most of us recognize good character in people. The question is: Do we act on what we recognize?
What does it really mean to value character in a political leader? It doesn’t mean that we demand that our leaders be perfect. We are all human and flawed. We have all made mistakes over the years. There is, however, a real difference between someone who has made mistakes in the past and someone who is just of poor character. Every human being makes mistakes. People of poor character look for ways to promote themselves. The damage they do is not by mistake. They choose to do the things they do. That is bad character.
While character is multifaceted, there are at least two elements of character that we should demand of our leaders: honesty and courage.
We should demand that our leaders be honest. They should be candid about the mistakes they have made in the past and give us good reasons to believe they will not make them again in the future. They need to own up to their own pasts. In order for us to know for whom we should vote, we absolutely must understand what the candidates will do if they are elected. And if, once in office, politicians lie to us, we should never vote for them again.
But don’t all politicians lie? The answer is no. And if it is more common today, then we have to fight against this trend. We all know that bad behavior always continues if there are no consequences. So why do we tolerate politicians who lie? Those we choose to hold office have tremendous power to shape the future of our country, and that means they have the power to affect the quality of our lives. If politicians never face any consequences for lying in office, then future political leaders will be encouraged to lie even more.
And we need leaders who are courageous. Those who lack this character trait will cave to the pressures around them and fail to live up to whatever principles in which they claim to believe. If our politicians are cowards, they will seek the easy path in order to win the praise of their followers. This was the main point of John F. Kennedy’s book, “Profiles in Courage.” In many ways, courage is what I would call the forgotten virtue. We don’t realize how important it really is until one of our leaders fails us.
Demagogues are dangerous in democracies because they lie to us in order to consolidate their power. The difference between a demagogue and what used to be called a statesman (there are clearly women, e.g., Margaret Thatcher, Golda Meir and others, who deserve a new word for this) is that statesmen seek to teach people to change their opinions. Demagogues take the coward’s way out and simply flatter people’s fears.
In a democratic republic like ours, politicians serve us; we do not serve them. So we should always be suspicious of politicians who praise us and tell us that our fears are justified. Are they really telling us the truth, or are they simply trying to gain power to use it for their own gratification?
Honesty and courage. This isn’t too much to ask of our political leaders. In fact, it should be the bare minimum. Why do we tolerate less than this? We all need to ask ourselves a serious question: why do we support liars and cowards? Are we just closing our eyes and following some kind of party line? Do we feel safer when we do this or do we just like just fitting in with others? Or are we just too lazy to ask the questions we should ask? Do we do this because we find it comforting that our prejudices are confirmed?
We must always remember that the way we act also reveals our character. And our government will ultimately reflect the character of its people.
Solomon D. Stevens was a professor of constitutional law, American government and political theory before retiring to North Charleston. He is a regular contributor to The Post and Courier Opinion section.

