In the wake of Thursday’s federal court decision to strike down several key parts of New York’s Concealed Carry Improvement Act, local, state and federal political leaders came out in favor of the decision.
In June, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a landmark decision to allow all Americans the Constitutional right to carry guns in public. In response, New York State enacted new requirements for obtaining a firearms license, and created a list of public and private places where it would be illegal to carry a gun. New York’s law went into effect Sept. 1.
On Thursday, District Court Chief Judge Glenn T. Suddaby, in Syracuse, issued a decision in a lawsuit that temporarily blocked some of the new requirements, while upholding others. The lawsuit was brought against New York State by six state residents and members of Gun Owners of America.
Suddaby’s decision will allow for concealed carry in some public locations, like bars, restaurants, libraries and zoos, while he also upheld the ban on concealed carry in government buildings, schools, houses of worship and other locations. Suddaby also struck down the need for new gun buyers to provide a list of family members and social media accounts, while maintaining the need for “good moral character”.
Suddaby also instituted a three day grace period to allow the state to respond in court before his decision took effect.
State Senator Joseph A. Griffo, R-47, Rome, said he is in favor of Suddaby’s decision.
“This law is unconstitutional. The sweeping changes made by the legislative majorities and governor in a hastened and nontransparent manner, much like the SAFE Act, came about without proper input from stakeholders and the general public, will burden local governments and small businesses and negatively affect law-abiding New Yorkers,” said Griffo in a statement.
“Proactive measures need to be taken to address the crime and violence sweeping our state, including focusing on mental health and illegal guns. However, these flawed changes will not make our state safer and will only infringe further on the constitutional rights of responsible gun owners.”
State Assemblywoman Marianne Buttenschon, D-119, Marcy, said she was also in favor of the decision.
“The Supreme Court ruling identified that there was clear subjective discretion in the New York State law. The legislation that was put forward in the recent special session, did not address this concern,” Buttenschon stated.
“I commend Chief Judge Suddaby for making a decision that suspends some provisions of this new legislation and hope that further motions during this suspension period prove that law abiding citizens deserve the Constitutional rights that have been provided to them regarding the ownership of a gun.”
U.S. Congresswoman Elise Stefanik, R-21, Schuylerville, agreed with Griffo and Buttenschon.
“Since the beginning, I have stood up against Hochul’s shameful attempt to shred our Constitution when she doubled down on her unconstitutional gun ban even after the United States Supreme Court struck it down. Her direct attack on our upstate values has wrongfully declared historical reenactors and lawful gun owners in the Adirondack Park as felons and ended gun show fundraisers for first responders in my district. This must come to an end now.”
New York State Conservative Party Chairman Gerard Kassar added, “U.S. District Court Judge Glenn Suddaby is correct in blocking several enforcement provisions in New York’s hastily passed new gun laws. The Constitution is clear on the Second Amendment, and efforts by New York Democrats to require social media background checks for gun purchasers, among other things, violate both First and Second Amendment rights.”
New York Assemblyman Robert Smullen, R-118, Meco, said, “This is further proof that the Second Amendment cannot be infringed with these unconstitutional measures rushed through Albany’s notoriously dysfunctional process. I encourage citizens to continue beating the drum on this issue until the new laws are fully repealed, in order to ensure the full protection of our constitutional freedoms as they were originally intended.”

