HomeFinanceHow to attract private finance for climate projects in developing countries –...

How to attract private finance for climate projects in developing countries – EURACTIV.com

During UN climate change conferences, developing countries look with scepticism at promises of funding from rich nations. To stimulate private finance, incentives are needed for investors to cross the border, writes Marilyn Waite.

Marilyn Waite is managing director of the Climate Finance Fund, board member of the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG), and board member of the EPA’s Environmental Financial Advisory Board (EFAB). 

Private finance and UN climate negotiations make for strange bedfellows. During COP26, when private financers joined climate action through coalitions such as the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero (GFANZ), talks of trillions being mobilised were often met with scepticism from the climate movement.

Many emerging markets and developing economy (EMDE) stakeholders, who still await the paltry $100 billion annual public finance support promised during COP15, were simply asking the broader finance community, “where is the money?”

The reality is, however, that private finance from wealthy countries was never designed for, nor had the intention of, investing in climate solutions beyond domestic borders.

Supporting renewable energy in low- or middle-income countries was just never engrained in the psyche of big banks nor a driver of commitments. The north star for most European and US-based private finance efforts has been and still is to decarbonise their balance sheets. And most of their balance sheets aren’t much in developing markets.

This critical caveat to the “Glasgow trillions,” that rich country climate finance is designed to stay in rich countries, has been lost in translation. 

While climate-friendly commercial and residential investments are increasing from the banks and asset managers that tend to join big-tent climate efforts, there has not been a special carve out for investing in less wealthy economies.

If one in four US dollars ever crosses any kind of national border, for climate investments, it’s less than 15%. The average bank’s auto loan book in the US will be moving from an internal combustion engine to an EV, but that shift in capital is for a car in the United States – not a car in Kenya. 

Another element that has been lost in translation is misinterpreting what assets under management (AUM) mean. The headlines speak of over $100 trillion AUM committing to net zero GHG emissions, yet it’s important to clarify that AUM does not mean investments.

Much of the AUM from asset managers is tied up in high-value stocks. In other words, just because an asset manager holds Apple stock does not mean those assets will be liquidated to finance a wind farm. AUM does not translate directly to real economy decarbonisation. 

To be sure, all of finance, including the more than $200 trillion available from private finance, has a role to play in achieving a just, equitable, diverse, and inclusive climate-friendly economy.

It does matter that we have all hands on deck among financers. However, the market rule is this: decarbonising a balance sheet in country A does not translate to mobilising climate-friendly capital in country B. 

What would move the needle to help private finance in a wealthy economy reach climate solutions in a less wealthy economy? Incentives. Incentives for lenders and investors to cross a border. 

First, there is no better way to scale climate solutions than to capitalise on local banks and community-based financial institutions (FIs). Local institutions understand their market best, including how to manage risks and capitalise on opportunities.

Wealthy economies can incentivise their banks to invest minority stakes in emerging and frontier market banks, specifically for climate lending. Triodos, for example, has invested in 90 FIs across 42 developing and emerging countries. 

A second incentive type would be one to protect against inflation. Inflation stood at 8.5% in March 2022 in emerging and developing economies. Many inflation-linked bonds exist worldwide, such as the US Series I Savings Bond, protecting investors in high inflation environments.

The creation of climate-focused inflation-linked bonds for developing economies would attract investors. This would also provide an opportunity for public budgets in wealthy economies to provide start-up capital for such products.

Inflation alone is not an emerging market phenomenon, and one of the critical barriers to cross-border transactions is exchange rate risk; incentivising local currency investment is critical. 

Finally, policymakers must unlock for EMDE climate what they have unlocked for retirement savings—tax-free or tax-deferred benefits.

For example, a Roth Individual Retirement Account (IRA) in the US is an investment vehicle that allows retail investors to save for retirement in a tax-advantaged manner: the investment can grow tax-free and be withdrawn tax-free after age 59½.

In France, the Plan d’épargne retraite (PER) allows for retirement savings aligned with tax reductions. Why not create a cross-border climate investment equivalent, available for retail retirement funds and institutional investors who hold the asset for 20-30 years? This would especially be helpful if the underlying assets are green financial institutions in EMDEs.

The solution to getting climate capital from rich economies to emerging ones will require a shift in mindset in the climate movement, including a recognition that climate financial regulations and incentives for private capital are not currently designed to cross borders.

To solve this, serious work “at home” to create incentives in wealthy economies must begin. 

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular