The dream top of the lineup of Silver Sluggers Tatis, Soto and Manny Machado—$56.8 million worth of star power alone this year—will not happen this season. And now even a playoff appearance for San Diego has become less likely.
At the time of the suspension the Padres were clinging to the last playoff spot, the third wild card berth in the NL. They were looking at playing the Cardinals in a best-of-three series all in St. Louis.
San Diego collapsed late last season as Tatis, playing with a shoulder injury that was not fully healed, hit .245 in his last 41 games. This year the Padres added the bats of Soto, Bell and Brandon Drury, another trade deadline acquisition, to guard against another collapse. They entered this weekend with the fewest home runs and worst slugging percentage of any National League contender.
Tatis was another big piece toward adding the thump San Diego would need to take on the Dodgers or Mets if it could get through a first-round series. He probably would have fit better into the lineup in the outfield—Padres outfielders are hitting .227 with only 29 homers—than displacing defensive whiz Ha-Seong Kim at shortstop. In either case, they would be adding the 2021 NL home run champion and one of the most exciting players in baseball.
The Padres still hold a dynamite rotation with swing and miss stuff. Yu Darvish, Blake Snell, Sean Manaea, Joe Musgrove and Mike Clevinger all strike out at least 8.6 batters per nine innings. And they have reached being in a playoff position with 48 games remaining without Tatis playing even one game. But make no mistake: Tatis is one of the five best players in the game who could have been a difference maker.
San Diego has learned that the guy it identified as its franchise player is not reliable. Because of injuries, motorcycle accidents, a PED bust and the COVID-shortened season, Tatis will not have played more than 130 games in any of his first five years in the big leagues, missing at least 43% of his team’s games.
The Padres in recent years committed $1.046 billion to sign or acquire Wil Myers, Eric Hosmer, Tatis, Machado, Soto, Hader and Musgrove. It is a spasm of spending unlike anything since the Diamondbacks tripled their payroll from 1998 to 2002. The Padres have pushed their payroll from consistently 20% below MLB average to 50% above it, which is generally regarded as unsustainable in their market without huge increases in revenue.
“Franchises almost never transform to the degree the Padres have,” said one high-ranking baseball source. “Spending ahead of revenue and team success to this degree.”
Soto is under contract through 2024, which means San Diego can still roll out the Tatis-Soto-Machado trio for two seasons (though not until May of next season), but Bell is a free agent after this season. In the meantime, the Padres will have to claw for just a playoff spot this year without Tatis providing the boost they’ve been counting on all year.
