However, legal experts are increasingly paying attention to the role of contracts in supply chain practices and looking for dedicated solutions. Last year, nonprofit Traidcraft Exchange launched a campaign to expand its Unfair Trading Practices Directive, which published a guide “for greater fairness in agricultural supply chains” in 2019, to the fashion industry and called for a Fashion Watchdog. The organisation has also petitioned the UK government’s Environmental Audit Committee to regulate purchasing practices in fashion, saying companies will never act fairly voluntarily, and that “stopping unfair purchasing practices is an essential precursor if the fashion sector is to have a hope of improving its social and environmental impacts”.
Through its responsible purchasing practices initiative, a working group of the American Bar Association (ABA) published in March a set of tools — a series of “model contract clauses” and a Responsible Purchasing Code of Conduct, or Buyer Code — that companies can incorporate into supplier contracts to improve human rights performance. The project came about because of what its organisers call a coherence gap.
“Companies are out there in the world saying they care about the treatment of workers in their supply chains, responsible business conduct and in fact they don’t align their legal and operational life with those public commitments,” says Sarah Dadush, Rutgers Law School professor and lead of the ABA working group’s Principled Purchasing Project. The contract clauses are meant to be a tool to close that gap, she says, and the response from brands they’ve spoken with to date has been positive. “There’s a real receptivity to the notion that contracts can be used to uphold, and that buyers share responsibility for, human rights performance.”
The Buyer Code and model contract clauses, which are voluntary to adopt and become legally binding once adopted, can also help companies stay ahead of tightening regulations, she says, such as the due diligence legislation expected in the EU. “There are real financial repercussions to not maintaining clean supply chains, and contracts can be a part of maintaining clean supply chains.”
When advocacy group Remake launches its updated transparency index later this month, it will include added metrics for evaluating brands’ purchasing practices and adoption of the Buyer Code. Remake’s advocacy and policy director Elizabeth Cline says the regulatory approach is more necessary than ever, because while the group’s Pay Up campaign helped suppliers win payments from brands that were being withheld early in the pandemic, things are already backsliding. “We’ve quickly returned to the race-to-the-bottom where factories feel they have to offer rock-bottom prices and unfair contract terms to stay in the game,” she says.
To become a Vogue Business Member and receive the Sustainability Edit newsletter, click here.
Comments, questions or feedback? Email us at feedback@voguebusiness.com.
More from this author:
Fashion’s new biodiversity benchmark
What fashion should expect at COP26
With $24 million raised, Evrnu wants to scale circular fashion

