The last time I met with Amanda Seyfried, it was a boiling-hot day in the summer of 2022, and she had just been nominated for an Emmy for her performance as Elizabeth Holmes in The Dropout, which she would go on to win. Between that and her 2021 Oscar nomination for her performance in Mank, it was clear her career was moving up to the next level. It wouldn’t be surprising if that kind of hype went to anyone’s head.
I’m pleased to report that Seyfried is exactly the same person she was three years prior when we meet again for her Who What Wear cover interview on a rainy October day in Brooklyn: immediately warm and chatty. She has a knitting project jammed inside an oversize and overstuffed Givenchy bag and is familiar in a way that makes you feel you’ve been friends for years. There is not an ounce of diva behavior to be found.
“To have any kind of spotlight on you for any particular reason in this awards realm is always helpful in terms of awareness. It was a reminder to people that I can show up and do good work,” she says of her two big award moments, tugging the sleeves of her black polo shirt over her hands. “But if you don’t keep working hard, doing what you love, but also making interesting choices, it fades. It all fades. The day after the Oscars clock strikes midnight, people already start talking about the next year.”
“It all adds up to this other person that is still you, very much you, but there’s a mountain on top of you, and this mountain has to be believable as a person,” she explains. “It was so fucking daunting, but it was like, ‘This is why these are the things that you choose.’ I feel like I have to keep choosing things that terrify me—within reason, right? I’m not gonna jump off a cliff or jump out of an airplane, but I need to sink my teeth into something that is really scary because I know I can do it, and I know I’ll be better for it.”
Fastvold had worked with Seyfried on both The Crowded Room and this year’s Peacock drama series Long Bright River, and the two had developed both an excellent working relationship and a close friendship, which came in clutch during the filming of The Testament of Ann Lee. When their families weren’t in town, Seyfried and Fastvold roomed together. Working with a tight indie-movie budget meant making the most of their time shooting in Budapest. Again, no diva behavior here.
“Amanda’s just a team player. That’s who she is, something that comes very easy to her,” Fastvold says over the phone. “When she’s not shooting, she’s working on her farm, feeding animals, doing that kind of work. She’s the opposite of whatever clichĂ© of a movie star is out there.”
The director also raved about Seyfried’s ability to connect with her costars, whether they were a day player or a seasoned actor. “She’s the most present and the most unafraid performer,” Fastvold says. “She’s so excited to just look into that other performer’s eyes and take whatever they’re giving to her and send it back.”
Explore More:

