
The battle between Kalshi and the state of New York is growing heated. An attorney for the the prediction market company warned they may have to stop all activity nationwide if a temporary restraining order goes into effect.
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul and state Attorney General Letitia James first announced a lawsuit against Kalshi in July for running what they called an “illegal gambling operation.” The state has sought a restraining order against Kalshi to keep the site from operating while the case is heard.
Kalshi’s attorneys argue that because the company is headquartered in New York, any enforcement action in that state will impact its ability to operate in other states. The Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which under Donald Trump’s administration has gone to bat for Kalshi and other prediction markets like Polymarket, has argued that any shutdown of Kalshi in New York would be an “existential threat” to the business.
The CFTC has sued twelves states that have sought to restrict or completely ban Kalshi’s activities in their states, including New York. On Friday, a federal judge rejected CFTC’s attempt to block New York from any enforcement action, according to Reuters. U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield in Manhattan wrote that the CFTC had “not established a likelihood of success on the merits” of its core argument, which is that the CFTC is Kalshi’s sector regulator, and that federal derivatives law preempts state gambling laws.
Utah has even brought criminal charges against Kalshi and its co-founders, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara.
Kalshi wants New York’s case to be heard in federal court, but the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York ruled Thursday that the case could proceed in New York’s Supreme Court. (Reuters noted that the new ruling against the CFTC nonetheless increases the chances that the case will eventually be heard by the U.S. Supreme Court.)
Kalshi spokesperson Elisabeth Diana told Gizmodo in an email Friday that it has followed the law and has been regulated by the federal government since the Biden era.
“Kalshi was certified as a federally regulated exchange under the Biden administration and has been compliant with the law since day one,” said Diana. “We want to work with the Governor and Attorney General on a resolution that protects the interests of the 1.2 million New Yorkers who use Kalshi.”
States have generally been allowed to make their own gambling laws, but the Trump administration has sought to protect Kalshi and Polymarket with their own lawsuits against state AGs. The president’s son, Donald Trump Jr., was hired as an advisor to both Kalshi and Polymarket when President Trump returned to office in 2025. Trump Jr. invested heavily in Polymarket, which led to a very public falling out with the company last week after Democrats stomped the GOP in this month’s midterm elections.
Kalshi argues that it’s not a gambling website because there’s no house and it doesn’t set odds. Users bet against each other, and the odds change based on how many people bet in one direction or another.
Prediction markets officially prohibit insider trading, but the definition of “insider trading” in any given context can be incredibly difficult to parse, given the wide variety of topics for wagers. That’s not even factoring in how difficult it can be to enforce. If your cousin’s wife randomly saw the playlist for the Super Bowl halftime show, and people are betting on the songs that will be played, is that insider knowledge? Even if it is, how can it be policed?
While the CFTC has generally defended the prediction markets under Trump, the regulator told Kalshi recently warned that it should shut down so-called “mention markets” about the president because they could be “readily susceptible to manipulation.” Mention markets allow people to bet on what words Trump will say. It was revealed over the summer that Trump’s now-former teleprompter operator, Gabriel Perez, made about $100,000 on those markets.
A New York Supreme Court court hearing has been set for 11:30 a.m. ET on Monday in New York.

