HomePoliticsWhat Faces Cuts in Democrats’ Social Spending Plan? | Politics

What Faces Cuts in Democrats’ Social Spending Plan? | Politics

Democrats are promising “transformational change” as they push for programs like universal pre-kindergarten, expanded Medicare benefits and paid family leave. But with political resistance within their own party to the estimated $3.5 trillion cost of the social safety net package, some parts will inevitably face cuts. Now members face the intricate exercise of deciding what exactly gets scaled back.

Complicating matters, House and Senate leaders as well as the White House are tasked with finding a compromise on the massive second half of President Joe Biden’s economic agenda that moderates and progressives can both support before a new deadline of passing the first part – a bipartisan infrastructure bill – by Oct. 31. The two bills are linked since progressives won’t support the infrastructure vote until the social spending plan is at least finalized.

Negotiations over revised top-line spending are ongoing, and moderate members were clear from the start they wouldn’t accept such an expensive package. That means Democrats might need to pare back their legislation by at least $1 trillion, if not more. Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia, one of two Democratic holdouts in the upper chamber, has set his marker around $1.5 trillion. The other, Sen. Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona, hasn’t publicly specified what she’d feel comfortable with to get her support. With Democrats pursuing the budget reconciliation process to pass the bill without needing any GOP votes, the party will need all 50 Democratic senators aligned in order to advance it.

And while it’s unclear what exactly will get cut in the social spending plan, there’s also debate over how to downsize the legislation. Democrats are trying to juggle warring factions of their party but need to carefully decide what priorities might take a hit since doing so will have real-world implications for millions of Americans – and potentially political ones, since party leaders vowed to strengthen health care, education and climate if they won full control of the government.

“We have some important decisions to make in the next few days so that we can proceed,” House Speaker Nancy Pelosi of California said earlier this week. “I’m very disappointed that we’re not going with the original $3.5 trillion. If there are fewer dollars to spend, there are choices to be made, but we will not diminish the transformative nature of what it is.”

The debate has centered on whether to completely take out key components of the package or reduce the number of years of each. This week, Pelosi indicated both scenarios are possible.

In a Monday letter, Pelosi wrote that a strong contingent in her caucus wants “to do fewer things well” – a position long-held by centrist Democrats, including the New Democrat Coalition. But on Tuesday, she alluded to the progressive view of reducing the number of years for programs first.

“Some have said they want to do everything, so we’ll have that discussion,” Pelosi told reporters Tuesday. “So mostly, we’d be cutting back on years and something like that.”

Political Cartoons

There’s also disagreement over who should qualify for benefits in the reconciliation bill. Manchin believes there should be “means-testing” to ensure help is going to working-class and lower-income families and individuals, which can also reduce costs of the package. But on a recent press call, Senate Budget Committee Chairman Bernie Sanders of Vermont argued that the middle class tends to get left out of receiving government assistance and maintains that the programs should be universal.

Regardless of how Democrats ultimately rein in spending, dozens of priorities are at stake. As of now, the wide-ranging 10-year plan would fund programs like tuition-free community college, affordable housing, 12-week paid family and medical leave, universal pre-K, child care assistance and expanded Medicare benefits that include hearing, dental and vision. Democrats are also seeking an extension of the child care tax credit created under their COVID-19 relief bill, which gives families $3,600 per child under age 6 and $3,000 per child between 6 to 18.

Democrats plan to fund their legislation by raising taxes on large corporations and wealthier Americans but have pledged not to for those earning less than $400,000.

The many pieces of the social spending bill address a range of communities across the country, including seniors, children and young adults, people of color, families and caretakers. Scaling back on some priorities could take a toll on certain groups and from a political perspective, are bound to frustrate activists and base voters who have a vested interest in these areas.

While the exact cuts are uncertain, one battleground is over health care. Moderates are more focused on extending Affordable Care Act subsidies that were also in federal pandemic relief legislation and closing the coverage gap in states that won’t expand Medicaid. Progressives say they’re committed to broadening Medicare, which they see as a way to get them closer to their goal of a “Medicare for All” health care system. Sanders said expanded Medicare benefits are “not negotiable.” Plus, another provision potentially at risk is the plan to allow Medicare to negotiate for lower drug prices.

Progressives, meanwhile, are in the camp of doing it all – or at least as much as possible given the new spending limits. They argue that there shouldn’t be false choices and won’t “pit child care against housing” or give the illusion of favoring one particular group. They would rather scale back the number of years, though they noted that cutting back certain programs like some climate-related ones would be difficult to execute.

“If we have to cut the numbers slightly, then we would reduce the number of years because the universality and the immediacy of benefits are absolutely critical. That’s more important than having it for the entire 10 years,” Congressional Progressive Caucus Chairwoman Pramila Jayapal of Washington said on a press call earlier this week.

But progressives’ patience with Manchin and Sinema – and some in the House Democratic caucus – is wearing thin when it comes to making more progress on negotiations. Sanders called on both senators to say what exactly they want out of the bill.

“We are prepared to negotiate. We are prepared to compromise. But we’re not going to negotiate with ourselves,” Sanders said on the call. “The time is now long overdue for Sen. Manchin and Sen. Sinema to tell us exactly where they are. What do they want to cut? What do they want?”

The administration is vocalizing a similar sentiment. Biden himself has met multiple times with Manchin and Sinema, and the White House says the president is eager to move forward with negotiations in order to advance both parts of his agenda. The infrastructure deadline also overlaps with Biden’s foreign trip to Italy, Vatican City and the United Kingdom at the end of the month.

“I’m not going to set new timelines here,” White House press secretary Jen Psaki said at Thursday’s briefing. “I will reiterate that we don’t feel that the time is unending and we feel it’s time to move forward with negotiations, move to a place where we have a unified package, but I’m not going to set a new timeline today.”

Biden is traveling to Connecticut on Friday to specifically highlight the child care component of the reconciliation bill. When asked by a reporter if the focus of the trip suggests a red line for the president, Psaki wouldn’t define what would be non-starters when it comes to potential spending cuts. But she notably mentioned the care economy being a priority for nearly all Democrats – a hint at possible alignment in the party and what could remain intact after tough negotiations.

“I don’t have any new red lines to set for you today,” she said, “but certainly addressing the care economy – child care is a part of it – is something that’s a priority and important to the president and important to many … if not the vast majority or every single member of Congress.”

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular